Pacifiers are lifesavers for both parents and their babies. It is an effective way to calm down the little ones once they start getting fussy. Whether you are at home, in the mall, or your car, it can instantly soothe babies and make them quiet. However, not all pacifiers will work, especially for breastfed babies.
Some pacifiers might cause nipple confusion amongst babies. It can also cause plugged milk ducts and sore nipples, among other problems for breastfeeding moms. Nonetheless, it is still an effective way to tame your baby. The important thing is that you are wise enough to carefully evaluate the possibilities and end up with the right choice.
Looking for the best pacifier for breastfeeding baby? If you are having a hard time deciding, keep on reading and learn from the insights we’ll share.
Using Pacifiers: The Good and the Bad
Before we talk about the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, let’s quickly take a look at its pros and cons. By weighing the benefits and the risks, it will be easier to decide whether to give in to pacifier use or give up the thought.
Among others, it is believed that the use of pacifiers reduces the risks of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). It also soothes babies with reflux or colic. Plus, it satisfies the natural need of babies to suck when the nipples of their moms are not available. It is also believed that it is a great way to encourage babies to control how they feel. When traveling on an airplane, it is also said that pacifiers can help soothe pain from air pressure.
Nonetheless, there are also some arguments against the use of pacifiers. For instance, babies might prefer it over nipples, making it difficult to have them breastfed. There have also been studies noting how it can result in ear infections and tooth problems. The germs on the pacifier can also make babies sick, so keep them clean.
At the end of the day, the most important is that you choose the right pacifier and that you use it properly. If that’s the case, then you have nothing to worry about!
Our Top Picks for the Best Pacifier for Breastfeeding Baby
If you have no idea about the best pacifier to buy, this section briefly looks at some of the top choices that are perfect for breastfeeding babies.
#1. BIBS BPA-Free Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier
Designed and manufactured in Denmark, this pacifier is second to none when it comes to the safety of babies. You can have peace of mind knowing that it does not have BPA, phthalates, and PVC, among other components that can be toxic for baby.
In terms of construction, this is made of natural rubber. It is soft and will make babies comfortable when they are sucking. However, take note that it is natural for the rubber to expand within a few months of use. With this, the manufacturer recommends replacing the pacifier after three or four months.
The rubber in the pacifier is also exceptional because it resembles the feel of the nipples, making it easier to transition from breastfeeding to using a pacifier.
This is also good if you are looking for value for money since it comes in a pack of two pacifiers.
#2. Evenflo Feeding Balance Plus Stage 1 Cylindrical Pacifier
The mere fact that this is from Evenflo can already give you a good reason to choose this over others. More than its brand name, the distinct shape of the pacifier is another asset. It has a cylindrical shape that will make babies feel like they are breastfeeding when they are sucking the pacifier.
The design of the pacifier gives it an edge over many others. It is soft so that it will reduce fatigue, even if it stays in the mouth of your baby for a long time. It is also easy to grip, making it effortless to hold for both babies and their moms.
You also don’t have to worry about cleaning the pacifier. It comes with a releasable bag that you can use up to five times to sterilize the pacifier.
#3. Nanobebe 2-pack Pacifiers
If you are looking for the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, make sure to include this on your list.
Nanobebe Pacifiers has a smart design that is made specifically for those who are breastfeeding, preventing nipple confusion.
You will also love the distinct shape of the pacifier, which allows it to fit like a glove in the mouth of babies. It stays on the mouth securely regardless of the movements your baby makes. This product also shaped in such a way that it helps in promoting oral development in newborns.
It comes with one-piece construction, which is in accordance with the guidelines set by the American Academy of Pediatrics. It is also phthalate and BPA-free.
For your peace of mind, it is also good to know that the manufacturer offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If you are unhappy with its use, let the manufacturer know and they will issue an unconditional refund.
#4. MAM Start Design Collection Pacifier
Based on market research conducted from 2010 to 2014, which includes 1,236 babies, MAM pacifiers are accepted by 94% of those who were observed. This is proof that you can never go wrong when giving this pacifier to your little angel.
Several smart design features will give this pacifier the advantage of many of its competitors. One that we liked the most is the nipple air channel, which improves airflow while the baby sucks. It is also extra-small that makes it lightweight. Despite the size, it is designed in such a way that babies won’t be able to swallow it. The silicone nipple is also a good thing, which feels like nipples. Lastly, there is an innovative shield with dimples, which will prevent skin irritation.
#5. Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Everyday Pacifier
This is manufactured by a company that is popular for its bottles specifically designed for breastfeeding babies. With this, you can expect nothing but the best with their pacifier. One of the highlights is the orthodontic nipple shape, which makes them feel comfortable and calm like they are breastfeeding. This orthodontic pacifier is also designed in such a way that it improves oral development.
Looking at the design, one thing that makes this impressive is the shield that comes with two openings on the side. This improves air circulation, allowing babies to breathe easily even when the pacifier is in their mouth. It also keeps the cheeks free of moisture.
Like most of the pacifiers that are included on our list, you will also love the safety of this product since it is BPA-free.
#6. Nuby Prism 2-pack Orthodontic Pacifier
This BPA-free pacifier is designed for babies who are six to 12 months. It has orthodontic silicone as the main material, which makes it soft and comparable to nipples. This is a great way to avoid confusion among breastfeeding babies.
The hygienic air system is also a plus. This also reduces skin irritation while making sure that babies can breathe properly even when they are sucking the pacifier.
#7. Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier
Moms would know that Philips Avent is one of the most trusted brands in the market for baby products, so you have a good reason to choose this pacifier. This is a brand that is used globally even by medical professionals to calm fussy babies, so you can be confident that it works.
The main material that is used in this pacifier is hospital-grade silicone. It is also latex and BPA-free, so you can be sure that it is safe for babies. There are no toxic chemicals that will put your little angels at risk.
You will also love how it is effortless to clean. To sterilize the pacifier, all that you need to do is to steam or boil it for five minutes. There is also a snap-on cap, which will allow you to clean it in the dishwasher.
#8. The First Years Gumdrop Pacifier
Like the pacifier from Philips Avent that we have mentioned in this post, this is also made using latex-free and hospital-grade silicone. It is trusted even by medical professionals, so you can be confident that it is completely safe for newborns and breastfeeding babies.
The unique contour shape is one more thing that you will love in this pacifier. It is lightweight, which prevents it from causing fatigue in babies even if they are using it for a long time. It also fits easily in their mouth without blocking the nose, which means that there are no breathing restrictions.
The manufacturer recommends this pacifier for users who are 0 to 36 months.
#9. Wubbanub Infant Pacifier
This is one pacifier that babies are sure to love because of its design. It is functional and stylish, making it a great addition to the playtime of the little ones. It is unique because there is a plush toy that connects directly to the pacifier. This also makes it easier to grip and reduces the likelihood that babies will swallow the pacifier.
Like most of the premium pacifiers that you will find in the market, this is made of medical-grade silicone that is free of BPA, phthalate, PVC, and latex, among other materials that can put babies at risk.
#10. Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier White Stage 1
Like the other pacifiers that are mentioned in this buying guide, this also mimics breastfeeding, which prevents nipple confusion. It comes with a soft and round durable nipple that babies can comfortably suck even for an extended period.
You will also like how it comes with a one-piece design. This means that there are no parts that will separate from each other, which minimizes choking hazards.
There are also large holes for air circulation, making it easier for babies to breathe even when they are sucking the pacifier.
The versatility of this product is also impressive. Aside from being a pacifier, babies can also use it as a teething toy.
Lastly, it is also effortless in terms of its maintenance. It is dishwasher-safe, but make sure that you put it only on the top rack.
#11. RazBaby JollyPop Baby Pacifier Plus
Recommended for babies who are three months and above, this is made of BPA-free and medical-grade silicone, so you can be confident that it does not contain toxic chemicals. It is widely distributed in hospitals, which is one more thing that can provide you an assurance of its safety.
With the orthodontic design of the pacifier, you will also love how it is easy and comfortable for the babies to use. Plus, it supports the natural oral development of your little ones.
It also comes with one-piece construction, which makes it durable and easy to clean.
As recommended by the manufacturer, this pacifier is best only for babies who are three months and above.
#12. Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifier Set
This nipple-shaped pacifier is another top option that will be well-loved by breastfeeding babies. Each pack comes with two pacifiers, making it deliver the best bang for the buck. The pacifier also has a one-piece construction.
The pacifier meets and exceeds ASTM requirements. It passed third-party tests, so you can be confident about its safety.
As for the construction, it is also made using 100% medical-grade silicone. By now, you most probably know that this is the material that you will find in premium pacifiers designed with the needs of breastfed babies in mind.
#13. Natursutten BPA-Free Natural Rubber Pacifier
The best thing about this pacifier is the material that is used, which is a pure natural rubber. It came from the Hevea Brasiliensi tree. This kind of rubber is softer than silicone, which feels more natural and comfortable, making it easier to mimic the feeling of breastfeeding. Compared to traditional pacifier designs, there is a larger shield in this model. This touches the nose and makes the experience similar to breastfeeding.
With the one-piece construction of this pacifier, there are no joints or cracks that can irritate the baby. This also makes it more hygienic since there are no gaps where bacteria can hide and accumulate.
Natural rubber, however, does not last long. It can easily deform. With this, the manufacturer recommends that you replace the pacifier every six to eight weeks.
#14. Joovy Silinoogie Pacifiers, Night Glow
Simplicity is one of the biggest selling points of this product. From its use to the way it is cleaned, you will enjoy how simple the pacifier is. There is a well-designed handle that will be easy to grip, even with the delicate hands of the babies.
One thing makes this good for breastfeeding is how it mimics the shape and feel of the nipple. It is made of soft silicone that will be easy for the baby to suck. The material does not contain BPA, phthalates, and PVC, among other toxic components. It is also a good thing that it does not absorb taste and odor. Plus, unlike other poor-quality pacifiers, the silicone does not get sticky.
#15. Chicco PhysioForma 100% Soft Silicone One-Piece Pacifier
If you have been shopping for baby products, Chicco is one brand that you can easily recognize, and this can assure you of the unmatched quality of this pacifier. Designed for babies who are 6 to 16 months. It is clinically-developed and tested. The safety is not just a claim made by the manufacturer, but one thing that has been proven even by medical professionals.
As for the construction of the pacifier, it is made using 100% silicone, which is latex and BPA-free.
Meanwhile, for the design, you will love how it comes with a lateral curve for the even distribution of pressure. It also has tiny ridges and an ergonomic shape to encourage the right placement of the tongue. This has a huge impact on the comfort of the user. To add, it has a narrow base that allows babies to close their lips properly without making it difficult for them to breathe.
How to Choose the Best Pacifier for Breastfeeding Baby
The options can be endless, but this should not give you the reason to settle with just any pacifier. As you try to narrow down your choices, below are the most important factors to consider.
- Material: It directly impacts the quality and safety of the pacifier, so this is an important consideration. Latex and silicone are two of the best materials. Make sure that it is baby-safe and non-toxic. It should also be soft and BPA-free. The material should also not cause allergies among babies.
- Size: Avoid giving pacifiers that are too small. There is a risk that babies can swallow it and it can result in choking. It should be large enough so that it won’t be easy to insert the entire pacifier in their mouth.
- Design: Choose a pacifier that is attractive enough for babies to love. More than the aesthetics, it should also be ergonomic. The design should be easy to grip and suck. Otherwise, babies will hate using pacifier. It is also good if it comes with a one-piece design, which makes it hygienic and reduces the chances that babies will accidentally swallow it.
Safety Tips when Using Pacifiers
For your peace of mind, take note of the tips briefly mentioned below to keep your baby safe and sound when using a pacifier:
- Keep it clean. One of the best ways to clean a pacifier is to sterilize it the same way you would do with feeding bottles. Pay attention to the specific instructions from the manufacturer on how to clean the pacifier.
- Make sure that there are air vents. This is a major requirement in pacifier design as it allows the baby to breathe even when the pacifier is in their mouth.
- Do not use a pacifier with a strap or string. While you might think that this reduces choking hazards, it is a bigger risk because it can wrap around the baby’s neck and can strangle them.
- Choose an age-appropriate pacifier. It should be suitable for the size of your baby’s mouth to minimize the possibility of choking.
- Replace the pacifier when needed. Otherwise, it will be a breeding ground for bacteria that can harm your baby. Look for signs of discoloration, stretching, scratches, and other damages.
Before we end this post, let’s answer a few of the questions that you might have about the use of pacifiers in breastfeeding babies.
When Should I Introduce a Pacifier to My Breastfed Baby?
According to the American Academy for Pediatrics, it is best to wait for three to four weeks after birth before using a pacifier for breastfeeding babies. At this time, breastfeeding has already been established, which will lessen the chances that there will be nipple confusion.
Can You Leave a Pacifier in a Baby’s Mouth While Sleeping?
This might seem risky at first, but this is safe. Leaving a pacifier in the mouth of babies is one of the best ways to lessen the likelihood of Sudden Infant death Syndrome, although, even doctors can accurately explain why this is the case.
How Do You Introduce a Pacifier to a Breastfed Baby?
There is no special way of doing this. However, the most important is that you wait until it is the right time. As earlier mentioned, this should be about three to four weeks after birth. Simply put the pacifier in the mouth of your child and keep an eye to prevent choking.
The best pacifier for breastfeeding babies is a must-have. It is one of the best ways for soothing babies once they start to get fussy. If you are worried about nipple confusion, all that you have to do is to choose wisely. From the design to the materials, consider a variety of factors to make the right decision. To make things easier, consider our recommendations in this buying guide.
Are there other pacifiers that you would like to add? Are there tips you would like to share? Don’t hesitate to write a comment below.